Muschamp Rd

Initial Observations of Civ V

January 17th, 2011

For the record in my first six games I went 4-1 with one NC. I lost Orleans and decided I’d be better off restarting only to learn Civ V no longer scores abandoned games. I could have perhaps rallied, but I had tried some different and apparently less effective things that game. I could have played more but felt I should write down some of my thoughts and observations and as a life time Side Meier game fan.

Hexes are Good

First things first, the hexes and the new combat system are great. I’m a peacenik, a builder, but now that combat is much more tactical I enjoy it more. I’m much more willing to engage in offensive campaigns especially against past foes and for a prize.

City States are Great

Second, City States are great, all my wins were a result of earning the trust and support of many city states even if I had to buy it. In fact I’d say winning diplomatically is the easiest way to win. It is the only way I’ve won besides the time out, which is really a hollow victory.

Wonders are still Wonderful

The documentation says Wonders of the World count the most towards your score and if you’re at peace you can try to optimize your civilization to maximize your score, that’s what I did during my one timeout victory. Usually I just build the United Nations and gradually buy enough votes to win.

Culture is still Important

Culture is still important though the cultural victory is much more difficult to achieve than in the previous two versions. Culture is important as it gives you Social Policies which really allow you to boost your Civ. So far I’ve only completed Patronage and Liberty I think. It has proven more effective to cherry pick rather than dogmatically complete one Social Policy after another.

What’s missing

The first thing I noticed is there is no slider. Every Civ game has had a slider. You can spend your production more on research or commerce or luxury. Now all that is controlled by the Social Policies, which if you don’t have much Culture you can’t use very much at all.

No more “g” for “go”

The real first thing I noticed is to move units it is no longer “g for go“. Every single Civ game has used the keyboard shortcut “g for go” now after over a decade of loyal support of the franchise, they change it to “m for move”. That is just dumb. Longtime customers like myself should be cherished not punished for learning old keyboard shortcuts. There is no good reason not to support “g for go” in Civilization V. This is bad software engineering, bad product design, and bad customer care.

No more pollution

Also missing is pollution. The original Civilization and more so some of the sequels had really harsh penalties for messing up the environment. Now you can build as many factories and nuclear reactors as you want with no pollution, no protests, nothing. As long as you have the resources you can exploit them. I’m not sure this is the right signal to send in 2011. I’m also betting this gets addressed eventually given the role pollution and cleaning up pollution played in previous editions.

No Congress to Appease

The senate or the congress no longer steps in. War mongers were formerly restrained somewhat if they ran a representative government. No more, it seems you can attack anyone you want and more importantly refuse to make peace. No one can force you to make peace, not even the UN. Though if you’re too aggressive your other neighbours will not be pleased, but it seems warmongers lost another obstacle to world domination.

What keeps the warmongers in check?

First, they changed the military victory conditions. Also individual cities are now tougher. It takes tactics not just the biggest stick to win a war. I haven’t tried but I suspect invading another continent is even more difficult. This was always hard, but warmongers just play on Pangaea or adjust some other game conditions to get what they want. Force them to play on the default map and some of their mojo disappears.

Cash is now King

My very first game was with Arabia. That is still my highest score. I used to try and maximize culture or research or both. Now the single most important factor to watch is your cash flow. Money = Power in Civilization V. You can use it to buy territory. You can use it to buy city improvements. You can use it buy units. You can use it to upgrade units. You can use it in trades. You need it to start research agreements. You don’t seem to be able to lend it to other Civilizations, but they’ll ask for gifts of cash.

Citizens enjoy Luxuries

Next to cash the most valuable things in the game are luxury resources. If your people aren’t happy they won’t kick you out of office, though they may rebel eventually. Mainly they just work less hard, fight less hard, farm less hard etc. etc. Not all luxury resources are created equal. Some like silver and gold can be converted to commerce, others can be converted to culture, some help with food production.

Strategic Resources aren’t Game Breakers

The computer Civs seem more willing to trade these for cash or luxury resources and if you don’t have one or two you can overcome your lack of resources. There are just some units and buildings you can’t construct. I still like Coal, Iron, and Horses as they are the first three. Horses can be used to make people happy. Iron lets you build Swordsmen and other early military units. Coal lets you build factories. I see no reason not to max out on factories now.

After years of playing Civ V I’d say you need enough coal to build three or four factories. You can survive without iron and horses.

Research is easier to produce than Culture

I know this because a lot of buildings increase research by a %, whereas most Cultural bonuses are fixed. I’ve achieved the 100 Research from a City but I’m not sure I’ve achieve the 100 Culture from a City.

Bigger Isn’t Better

Expanding your empire has to be weighed by how unhappy it will make your existing citizens. Unhappiness is primarily the product of number of cities and population. This may seem a bit odd, but it makes you build up a surplus of gold and happiness before expanding. It also keeps your overall empire size in check even when you are clearly leading. Padding your score is no longer as easy as it once was.

I’m not sure War Weariness is still a factor.

I like the sharing of badges/accomplishments. This makes all the lonely nights somewhat worthwhile at least for bragging purposes, that said my computer barely runs the game and I’ve yet to try multiplayer. I’m not sure why the downloadable content doesn’t work on the Mac either.

If you have thoughts on Sid Meier’s Civilization V as for some reason like me you have not moved on to Beyond Earth or version VI you can leave them below. I sacrificed many years of my life to passing all three CFA® exams and eventually will get a new job, a new computer, and can relax and enjoy life more.


  • Muskie says:

    I’ve played a couple more times, ten total I think. My favourite Civilizations are Arabia, China, and Siam. I tried playing on a more difficult setting and was doing well until I stayed at war too long without upgrading my military tech enough. Suffered my first blitzkrieg from Ghandi of course. I want to play again, but I also have to prioritize my free time better too.

  • Muskie says:

    Another thing that is missing that has been in every other addition is the ability to name yourself and the cities you found.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Posts on Muskblog © Andrew "Muskie" McKay.
CFA Institute does not endorse, promote or warrant the accuracy or quality of Muskblog. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.