Muschamp Rd

BlogLevel VS Klout VS Technorati

July 15th, 2011
Klout logo

So sometime in the last 24 hours a Tweet appeared on my phone from one of Vancouver’s more famous writers talking about a tool released by Edelman.  It so happens I know some people who work in the Vancouver office as the non-profit I used to work for actually had them as advisors on some tricky issues facing the Downtown Eastside.  Edelman has built and released a tool to measure online influence AKA popularity.My BlogLevel

They appear to have two related tools: TweetLevel and BlogLevel.  TweetLevel measures a Twitter account and BlogLevel measures a blog URL.  So I plugged in @MuskieMcKay and blog.muschamp.ca for a laugh.  The system produced a number and some pretty generic advice on how I could do better.

The problem with these tools is they don’t know I’ve been online and building the web since 1995.  They don’t seem to look as far back as 2005 when my blog started, they seem to consider the most recent posts in my RSS feeds.  They don’t know I could probably pass myself off as a WordPress guru or a social media expert.  The tools also don’t consider all the guest blogging I’ve been doing. Their tools do have a mascot who is some sort of bird with a monocle. He has a top hat and a cane or wand too. According to their system Neil Gaiman is the most influential person on Twitter, take that Justin Bieber!

Popularity isn’t everything, but I can’t help thinking Neil Gaiman puts a little more thought into his tweets than Justin Bieber.  I don’t follow either account and don’t really think I’d buy a car or some shoes if Neil Gaiman or Justin Bieber told me to.

My TweetLevel

Of course while using these tools I thought, we’ve seen all this before.  Klout wants to be the standard for online influence.  I checked my Klout score it is holding steady at 50.  Klout also thinks I’m an expert on beer.  Measuring blog popularity is an even older game online.  Technorati was all about that, but you never hear a peep about Technorati these days.  They are either passe or just plain crushed by Google and the other big players online.  The website is still operational, I don’t know what my Technorati ranking is for Muskblog.  The Top 100 has the Huffington Post as the top blog at least in the English speaking world.  I can’t help recall that English language speakers are going to be a minority if they aren’t already online and Chinese is really the language to know if you want to influence the masses.

Didn’t see Guy Kawasaki in the top of the Top 100.  I kept linking to him for a while, but lately he just isn’t producing as compelling of content for free at GuyKawasaki.com…

I’ll take a wait and see approach to these new tools.  I don’t think there is room for too many niche players in the blogging/tweeting/social media influence game.  Google, Microsoft, Facebook, Apple, Amazon they all have social strategies and a lot more clout than Klout or Edelman or Technorati.

Update March 21st 2012

People still worry about their Klout score or at least wonder why it isn’t higher or why they have “army” Klout. I’m not sure my exact Klout score at the moment and I definitely haven’t checked TweetLevel or Technorati since this post. Others have been paying attention to the niche that is measuring influence online. TechCrunch has an article on a recently released report.

Klout still doesn’t measure Disqus or posts to more than one blog. I think more work also needs to be done on measuring commenting and curating.  Pinterest is still the newest social media darling or perhaps OMGPOP which was purchased today. I keep trying to stay on top of so many things and largely failing. Also making the rounds today on my Twitter feeds is a tale of how a Reddit user parlayed some posts into a screen writing deal. As someone who has been unable to convince anyone to hire me for too long, I’m always reading the latest ways to leverage online communities and online reputation in your job search. I’m not as popular as I used to be and maybe I don’t come across as desperate and destitute enough, but after not getting yet another job I interviewed for I’m close to throwing in the towel.

My heart definitely isn’t in studying for the CFA exam and I still haven’t recovered from my MBA regardless of what the administration at the Sauder School of Business would like everyone to believe. I’ve spent a lot of time helping people, the community, classmates, strangers, and it just hasn’t paid off. Regardless of Klout score or my resume, I’m not what a lot of employers are looking for regardless of what language they use in their recruiting ads.


  • Jonny Bentwood

    Hi

    Thanks for posting about these tools, we are really proud of them.

    I’d like to stress the importance of context – the way that we use the tools are as an analytics and measurement aid. Have you tried the topic/hashtag search which gives you valuable data as to what people are saying within any given conversations as well measuring buzz, shared web links and most relevant people. 

    Cheers, Jonny
    Creator of TweetLevel and BlogLevel
    @jonnybentwood:twitter 

  • No worries, I’m just glad someone reads my blog from time to time.  I’m not the biggest self promoter.  I know the tools are still in development, if my review wasn’t the kindest.  These tools are fun to fool around with but Muskblog and my personal Twitter account don’t really exist to sway the masses.  One other service I reviewed that would be competition is Topsy.  You don’t hear much about Hi5 or Friendster or Bebo now a days and I think some other services and tools will fall into obscurity with the Googles and the Microsofts and the Apples fighting it out in the social space.

    I’m not against niche sites.  The most passionate people about a give topic create a disproportionate amount of the copy online about a give topic.  If they choose a niche site, it will survive and prosper.  I once opined that “Twitter was for keeners and Facebook was for grandmas.”  The danger facing Twitter now is the keeners will move to Google+.  Personally I think the keenest internet users should build their own homepage and aggregate data from other sites, that would be for the best.  Having a corporation own your identity online is going to cost some people eventually.

    Of course someday we’ll all be born with a chip in our spine and that can serve as our unique identifier online and off…

  • Pingback: Mengukur Pengaruh Blog dengan BlogLevel ! Muso9.com()

  • Technorati just wrote me an email.  Some sort of “Blogger outreach”.  Maybe they noticed I quested whether they were still in business.  It’s just a mass email probably went to millions.  It seems to they want me to blog on key topics or something so they can sell adds.  They also want me to blog elsewhere about my travels.  Both moves seem to reek of desperation.  Why would I go through all the trouble of setting up my own blog, only to write elsewhere for Technorati’s benefit?  Apparently I can win a prize of something.  Ditto them telling me what to write on my personal blog.  I thought the whole point of a personal blog was writing about whatever you want.  I can stick on topic.  I can even keep to a weekly publishing schedule when other people don’t let me down, but Muskblog is just a personal blog.  It isn’t a manifesto.  There is no mandate or agenda.  Even I think I’m stupid sometimes when I write about things, I can always delete, but I try not to be to hypocritical.  Dig your bed and lie in it and all that.  Good luck to Technorati, them and IceRocket don’t seem to be getting much press, maybe they should release iPhone apps.  That always gets press.  ;-)

  • Pingback: Superbowl hammers home superiority of Twitter – Muskblog()

  • Pingback: Topsy.com VS Klout.com – Muskblog()

Posts on Muskblog © Andrew "Muskie" McKay comments not necessarily so...
CFA Institute does not endorse, promote or warrant the accuracy or quality of Muskblog. CFA® and Chartered Financial Analyst® are registered trademarks owned by CFA Institute.